When Livy delivered a letter to Cherie, Lulu immediately recognized the seal of Prince Arsenio. Cherie opened the letter and a holographic version of the Prince told to her that he came to Pixieville. Cherie thought that he came to beg for forgiveness, but then he told that he has gone to marry. Cherie made-up a plan to make him jealous, so she "hired" Martino as her fiancé. On the party, Arsenio arrived and introduce his future bride: Miss Gypsy Gipps. But Cherie's plan failed, because Arsenio was not jealous on Martino, Martino and Arsenio became best friends. When Cherie walked into the hall of the Pixie Plaza, she saw Gypsy Gips and 3 butlers talking to each other. Then she saw that "Gypsy Gips" was really Maxine and the butlers were Rex, Floxy and Narcissa. With the help ofChatta's Pop Pixie Powers, Cherie heard that the 4 Elves put a bomb into the cake and want to steal the golden scepter of Arsenio. Cherie and Martino tried to unmask the Elves, but they failed and get expelled from the party. After that, Amore give them a magic potion that when someone drinks it he or she is forced to tell the truth. They succeeded to get the potion into Maxine's mouth, she told to Arsenio that she was an Elf and she and her friends want to steal his scepter. Arsenio became very disappointed, but then the bomb exploded and the podium was set on fire. Into the chaos, Rex steals his scepter and run away together his friends. But Cherie, Caramel and Martino succeeded to stop them and Arsenio gets his scepter back. After that Arsenio says goodbye to Cherie, because he lost his trust in love. He said he came back to Pixieville when he found his trust back.
- Arsenio is the Italian form of the Latin name Arsenius, which means "Male, Strong, Virile".
- It is unknown how Arsenio and Gypsy Gips actually met each other.